Justice Moraes Asserts Brazil’s Sovereignty Amid U.S. Criticism
Brazilian Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes defended the nation’s sovereignty in light of U.S. criticism. He affirmed Brazil’s independence and stressed the importance of upholding democracy and human rights. Amidst ongoing controversies surrounding digital platform regulations, Brazilian justices, including Chief Justice Barroso, pledged to protect constitutional integrity and national sovereignty against external interference.
On Thursday, September 27, 2023, Supreme Court Justice Alexandre de Moraes of Brazil responded to criticism from U.S. officials regarding his rulings on digital platforms. He emphasized Brazil’s sovereignty, asserting that the nation is independent and no longer operates as a colony. He stated, “We ceased to be a colony on September 7, 1822, and with courage, we are building an ever-stronger republic—an independent and democratic republic under the 1988 Constitution.”
Justice Moraes addressed the importance of defending democracy and human rights during the 73rd anniversary of the United Nations. His remarks followed a decision by the U.S. House Judiciary Committee to endorse a bill potentially barring him from entering the United States. The proposal remains to be voted upon by the full House, where the Republican majority prevails.
The controversy arose when Mr. Moraes ordered a ban on the right-wing video platform Rumble due to its refusal to comply with local regulations, including appointing a representative in Brazil. Recently, Rumble had litigation against him in Florida, after the platform refused to censor pro-Bolsonaro content. During a recent lecture, Mr. Moraes criticized technology companies, asserting they are not neutral entities.
In support of Mr. Moraes, Chief Justice Luís Roberto Barroso pointed out the struggles Brazil faced against coup attempts. He emphasized that the Supreme Court would continue to protect the Constitution and that lies would not scare them. Justice Flávio Dino also expressed solidarity with Mr. Moraes, highlighting the commitment of justices to uphold constitutional principles.
Finally, Justice Gilmar Mendes reiterated the significance of national sovereignty, affirming Mr. Moraes’ prudent actions to protect Brazil’s constitutional order. Moreover, the Brazilian Association of Federal Judges advocated for judicial independence and national sovereignty in light of the ongoing criticisms.
The remarks made by Justice Alexandre de Moraes reflect Brazil’s commitment to its judicial sovereignty amidst U.S. criticism. Emphasizing independence and democratic values, Brazilian justices united in their support following threats of U.S. intervention. This situation underscores the ongoing tensions surrounding digital censorship and the role of global tech companies in national governance. The Brazilian judiciary remains steadfast in upholding the Constitution and resisting external pressures.
Original Source: valorinternational.globo.com
